Murray's Cheese Blog

Fall is a good time to be a cheese lover. At Murray’s, our staff and customers look forward to a proliferation of incredible seasonal cheeses come October and November. One of those standouts is Rush Creek Reserve from Uplands Cheese Company in Southwest Wisconsin. To learn more about how this rich, custardy wheel is made, we talked to Uplands co-owner Andy Hatch for the inside scoop on this scoop-able masterpiece.

Uplands produces just two (incredibly delicious) cheeses: Rush Creek Reserve and Pleasant Ridge Reserve. Why is that? 

We’re focused on making cheeses that taste like our farm. That means we only use milk from our own cows, and we make our two cheeses during certain parts of the year, to show off the character of the milk during that period. 

Where did your inspiration come from for Rush Creek Reserve? What makes it unique? 

Rush Creek Reserve is inspired by Vacherin Mont d’Or, which I learned to make as a young apprentice working in France. But while the French version is often sold at 25-30 days old, U.S. law requires raw milk cheese be aged for at least 60 days. We initially looked at that as a curse, but we’ve come to see it has a marvelous benefit. The extended ripening coaxes some really deep flavors out of Rush Creek, which sets it apart from most younger soft-ripened cheeses. 

Why do you produce Rush Creek only during the fall? 

We milk our cows seasonally, and since they all calve in the spring, in time with the pastures, they are entering late lactation in the fall. This, combined with the change in weather and the start of hay feeding, produces milk much richer in fat than that coming from summer pasture. This richer milk is ideal for the custard-soft texture of a cheese like Rush Creek.

Tell us a little bit more about Uplands’ dairy farming methods. How do they affect the taste and texture of your cheeses? 

We are a seasonal, pasture-based dairy farm. Our cows all calve in the spring, in time with the emerging pastures, and we milk them through the end of the year before drying them off for the winter months. Pleasant Ridge Reserve, our aged Alpine-style cheese, is made while our cows are grazing fresh pasture, and it’s designed to show off the character of that grass-fed milk. Conversely, Rush Creek Reserve is made in the fall, as the milk becomes richer, and is designed to show off the texture of that autumn milk. 

Why did you decide to craft your cheeses in Wisconsin? 

I was born and raised here, as was my wife, Caitlin. And although I worked all over Europe as a cheesemaking apprentice, there’s nowhere I’d rather milk cows and make cheese than southern Wisconsin. We benefit from a long dairy legacy here, but at the same time, we encourage innovation in a way that you don’t often see in the old world. That’s a rare combination. I’m not sure a career like mine, buying a farm and making independent, original cheeses, would have been possible in Europe. 

What’s your favorite way to enjoy Rush Creek Reserve? 

On a dinner plate, alongside roasted meats and vegetables. The special sauce. 

What’s your vision for the future of Uplands? 

We’re committed to our pasture-based approach to farming and to making cheeses that reflect the character of this farm. To that end, we envision growing our two cheeses to the point where we fulfill the productive capacity of our 500 acres. We like to grow slowly, and our trajectory likely has us doubling over the next 10-15 years, as we have over the past 10. 

The next step is building a new, larger creamery, which is on the books for 2023. In addition to adding cheesemaking capacity, we’d like to give ourselves the ability to interact more with the public. We think that onsite engagement and education is going to be important to the future of American artisan cheese. 

A third cheese isn’t out of the question someday but not imminently. We’re still in love with exploring and improving Pleasant Ridge and Rush Creek. The seasonality of our farm brings constant renewal, and it never gets old. 

---

The 2022 batch of Rush Creek Reserve has arrived! Don’t miss the once-a-year opportunity to try this truly special cheese made with care by Andy and his team. 

While we’d love to chat with our favorite cheesemakers any day of the week, International Women’s Day provided an incredible opportunity to talk with two of the most influential women in cheese. On Tuesday, March 8, Murray’s Cheese’s Elizabeth Chubbuck shared the virtual stage with Adeline Druart of Vermont Creamery and Lynn Giacomini Stray of Point Reyes Farmstead Cheese Co. on Instagram Live. As they talked and tasted their way through an engaging cheese-filled hour, viewers got an inside look at what it means to be a leading woman in the industry and how these women are working to influence the food world. 

Kicking things off was Murray’s CSO Elizabeth Chubbuck, who leads the company’s strategic growth initiatives across a diverse ecosystem of businesses. She welcomed Lynn Giacomini Stray, who serves as co-owner, COO, and president of sales at Point Reyes Cheese, overseeing dairy operations, cheesemaking, marketing, and more; and Adeline Druart, president of Vermont Creamery, an artisan cheesemaker who has scaled the New England business into a leading national goat cheese brand. 

Lynn, Adeline, and Elizabeth each brought a cheese to share what their brands are all about—as they tasted through them, their excitement about their own and each other’s cheeses was palpable. Lynn shared Point Reyes Original Blue, a kitchen workhorse with a creamy texture. Bright milk flavors up front, with the classic blue cheese peppery pungency in the finish. They enjoyed the balance of the salty blue with the rich and coffee-tinged Zotter Chocolates Tiramisu Bar.  Adeline’s pick was Vermont Creamery Coupole, a buttery goat’s milk cheese with a gorgeous wrinkled rind and texture like whipped cream cheese. Elizabeth rounded out the array with Murray’s Cave Aged Original Buttermilk Basque, a snackable sheep’s milk cheese with a springy, mouthwatering bite. 

Between tastes, each participant talked openly about the impact they’re trying to make in the world of cheese and beyond. One topic that continued to come up was sustainability, a key issue for both businesses. Speaking in front of a brightly colored background of cows in a grassy pasture, Lynn highlighted that Point Reyes is a third-generation family business, which brings with it the important role of ensuring the land is viable for generations to come. She also discussed the farm’s methane digestor, which collects methane from wastewater and turns it into energy. Adeline explained that Vermont Creamery, a certified B Corporation, partners with existing infrastructure to stay sustainable. The creamery has also started sending its byproducts—whey and buttermilk—to a farm that turns it into natural gas.  

Elizabeth also asked Lynn and Adeline about who has inspired them. “I don’t think there’s any other industry that is quite like the cheese industry as far as its support and collaboration,” Lynn shared. She specifically shouted out Cowgirl Creamery founders Peg Smith and Sue Connelly for helping to build a community of cheesemakers in Marin County, which has transformed into a thriving cheese epicenter. Adeline spoke about Allison Hooper, co-founder of Vermont Creamery, who supported her in her journey from intern to president. She also highlighted how the company has worked to support women in manufacturing, often a male-dominated industry. Vermont Creamery served as an advocate in the creation of a Vermont bill for universal childcare—a concrete way to support women and parents in the workplace.  

And as for that elusive work-life balance that often plagues women in business? For Lynn, there’s no distinct separation between the two; she describes it all as part of her lifestyle. And for Adeline? “Work-life balance is overrated,” she said, explaining that attaining a perfect balance is impossible and everyone’s just doing their best. Elizabeth noted the concept of “work-life integration” and the importance of budgeting your own personal energy. 

While each of these women has had their unique journey in the food world, they all share a vision and a passion for building businesses that support other women and the environment. “Cheese is really just the platform for us to do all these other great things,” Lynn explained, highlighting a concept that surfaced throughout the event. For more inspiring insights from Lynn, Adeline, and Elizabeth—on everything from gender parity to beverage pairings—and to shop from women-owned creameries, visit our website. 

Any family that’s three generations deep into dairy is one that we respect. Enter von Trapp Farmstead, a family-owned farmstead cheesemaker nestled in the rolling hills of Vermont. And their award-winning cheeses, each one a testament to the family craft, can now be found at Murray’s—pungent, puddingy Oma, buttery Mad River Blue, and toasty sweet Savage. 

The history behind von Trapp cheese is extensive. Owner Sebastian is carrying on the legacy of the von Trapp family, specifically his grandparents, Erika and Werner, who brought their knowledge of agriculture from Austria and established the family farm in Waitsfield in 1959. To modernize the family business, each generation has given it their own unique twist. While Sebastian’s parents gained organic certification for their milk, Sebastian was the one to incorporate cheesemaking, adding the on-site creamery in 2009. A mixture of Jersey, Normande, Montbéliarde, and Ayrshire cows roam the verdant farm, producing milk with the perfect ratio of fat to protein for cheesemaking. 

With a single bite, you can taste the care that the family pours into their cows and cheesemaking. Oma is steeped in family history, named for Sebastian’s grandmother Erika. Washed in brine, this cow’s milk cheese develops a pungency that balances with its innate sweetness—think browned butter and roasted nuts with cured bacon. The pudding-like consistency is soft and melts over the tongue, but it’s never runny, the roasty notes best with a Belgian-style dubbel ale. 

Mad River Blue, meanwhile, highlights the family’s deep roots in Vermont. Named for the Mad River valley where the von Trapp farm has stood for decades, this buttery and mild cow’s milk blue is made from the farm’s certified organic milk. Its natural rind encases a dense, fudgy paste streaked with moderate blue veining that lends a gentle bite. Flavor-wise it’s complex, with notes of anise and cocoa layered against a strong savory undertone. Delicious with dark chocolate and juicy berries for dessert. 

And last but not least—Savage. Don’t let the name fool you, as this cheese is fairly easygoing. A cave-aged Alpine beauty that bursts with toasty notes of caramelized onion and beef broth. Ideal for melting: incorporate into a quiche or frittata or a truly exceptional grilled cheese. You can tease out the subtle sweetness of the certified-organic milk by pairing Savage with savory treats like beef salami or french onion confit. 

Not only are their cheeses unique, but the von Trapp family is also committed to sustainable regenerative farming. So go ahead and take a bite of these carefully crafted cheeses that are fresh in at Murray’s. To learn more about von Trapp Farmstead—from their incredible products to their earth-friendly ethos—visit their website. 

---

Calling anyone who’s hungry for cheese! But also anyone who’s hungry for cheese knowledge, cheese pairings, and a sense of connection with the cheese-loving community. Murray’s has launched another month of virtual classes and our virtual instructors can’t wait to see your virtual faces for some virtual cheese tasting. Let’s take a peek at why this at-home gourmet experience is one that’s truly unique. 

You get to take a curated journey through the world of cheese. 

From your kitchen table or your living room or even your bed, if you want. Each of our virtual classes has a well-chosen theme, whether it’s seasonal (think Cheddar Weather or Beer, Whiskey, and Cheese for St. Patrick’s Day) or evergreen (like Cheese 101). Whatever you choose, a diverse selection of cheeses is expertly curated, carefully wrapped, and sent directly to your door. All you need to do is plate your cheeses (using a Murray’s guide) and click the Zoom link, and you’ll be in the knowledgeable hands of a Murray’s instructor as you taste your way through the world of cheese, from bloomy to blue and everything in between. It’s an incomparable and easy opportunity to explore new cheeses and to discover why you like certain varieties (be sure to take notes so you’re prepared the next time you go to the cheese counter!). 

It’s not just the facts; it’s a full sensory experience. 

In an hour-long class, you’ll gain wheels of new cheese knowledge, all of which will come to life as you taste together with your classmates. In one recent wine and cheese pairing class, for example, John from Murray’s education team shared that sheep’s milk has twice the amount of fat of cow’s milk—as attendees soaked up this knowledge, they got to experience the extra creaminess that coats your palate with a spoonful of sheepy Brebirousse d’Argental. When John encouraged everyone to take a sip of prosecco after a ripe, gooey bite, it became clear how a sparkling wine can reset your taste buds. Every piece of information is rooted in the joy of experiencing new tastes. 

Your instructor will always remain accessible and interesting—never didactic. 

If you’re imagining this as a boring Zoom lecture, think again. You won’t find any monger-splaining here. Murray’s instructors aren’t just cheese experts—they’re genuinely excited to share the joy of cheese with the world. That enthusiasm is apparent even on the computer screen as they bring a sense of knowledge and passion to every cheese and pairing. They taste along with you and excitedly share their favorite anecdotes and facts, from exploring how the tongue processes flavor to explaining why American and English Cheddars taste different. And while they’ll guide you through general tasting and pairing principles, you’re always encouraged to discover what pops for your particular palate. 

It’s a fun way to find a community of fellow cheese lovers. 

While our classes are hosted in a webinar format, the chat is always open. That means you can ask your instructor all your burning questions about cheese making, cheese eating, cheese pairing… whatever’s on your mind. Plus, you can chat with your classmates, individuals from across the country who also wanted to spend their weekend eating cheese—we think you’ll have a lot in common. You can share what beverages you’re pairing or where you go for cheese board ideas with people who share your passion. 

You’ll impress your friends with a perfect cheese board made from leftovers. 

A few days in advance, you’ll receive a box with all the cheeses you’ll be tasting in class. And we send way more than a single bite! It’s enough for four people to take the class together at your home, making for a super delicious social gathering that’s full of conversation starters. But if you take the class alone or don’t make it through all the cheese within an hour, you can always craft an incredible cheese board in the days following your class. As you share in a cheese and wine tasting with friends, you’ll be the expert, sharing everything you learned as you spread, slice, and crumble your way thought a delicious evening. It’s a class that keeps on giving. 

---

As we reach the tail-end of winter, don’t get bored—get board. Explore all of our March virtual cheese classes here and choose the one that’s right for you. 

We recently partnered up with Instagram-influencer and self-taught chef, Quin of @ButterBeReady, to develop a meaty deep-dish pizza recipe, featured on Great Taste. (If you haven’t tried it yet , you must!) True to style, she created a picture-perfect pie that may taste even better than it looks. We sat down with Quin to find out more about her background and what inspires this black maker.

How long have you been creating dishes? What inspired you to start cooking?

I started my blog, Butter Be Ready, in 2016. I loved going to farmers markets and immersing myself into all of the food. I enjoyed the cooking process as a form of therapy and loved the various ways of bringing a dish to life. Back in college, I really wasn’t a good home cook. (I ate out more than I care to admit.) So, I wanted to learn better ways to make food at home. It wasn’t long before I created my own recipes (after testing and testing). Friends, co-workers, and family began asking me for the recipe. Butter Be Ready was a way to document and keep track of whatever I was making and to share it with folks.

What’s your favorite meal to make for a group of friends?

My favorite thing to put together is often an assortment of goods. With multiple people, I always find it important (and fun) to lay out all kinds of food for everyone to nosh on. I usually have a few appetizers like chicken wings, dips/spreads, and a cheese plate. If I had to make a meal, specifically, it would be some sort of pasta dish. My friends and I love pasta—anything creamy and extra saucy is my go-to meal.

Are there any chefs who have had an impact on you and your cooking?

Yes, absolutely! As a home cook with a black, Caribbean ethnicity and background, I’m deeply inspired by the works of my ancestors. Edna Lewis, Leah Chase, Carla Hall, and a few more had an impact on me and my cooking.

What’s your favorite thing about life as a content creator?

I’ve been a food entrepreneur for a little over 2 years now and it is wildly fulfilling. My favorite thing about creating recipes and other content is the level of freedom that I have built for myself. In addition to that, I enjoy having full creative control and autonomy of the work that I produce. Being able to develop recipes, share them with others, and then hear the feedback… that’s gold to me. I love the work that I do because food, photography, and creating art surrounding food is my passion. 

Do you have any pizza secrets you’re willing to share—how to get that perfect crust and your go-to cheeses?

For the perfect crust, I’d say get the oven up to the highest temperature that it can go-to. Don’t be afraid to oil your pan or skillet super well—this leads to a lovely crispy crust. My go-to cheese for pizza is definitely mozzarella! Pizza is nothing without the cheese pulls, and you’ll want lots of mozzarella for that melty goodness. Honorable secondary mentions include fontina and provolone.

Who would you invite to your ultimate pizza party?

Great question! I’d love to invite Oprah Winfrey, Ina Garten, Julia Turshen, and Michael Twitty. 🙂

Love what you see? Check out more of Quin’s recipes on her web site, Butter Be Ready.

You’ll find southern-inspired snacks, Caribbean-style meals, and more! And don’t forget to explore products from more black makers at Murray’s!